PDA

View Full Version : Student Review: Hunter x Hunter


Panwolf
10-17-2006, 04:57 PM
Title: Hunter x Hunter
Genre: Action / Adventure / Fantasy
Company: Nippon Animation
Format: 92 episodes, including the two OVAS, Gen'eiryodan and Greed Island.
Dates: October 16, 1999 – March 31, 2001

Grade: 97%

The world is mysterious, filled with wonders and untold stories. There are people that seek the riches of the earth and aim to discover everything there is to discover. These people are called Hunters.

Summery
Enter Gon, a charismatic boy with high aspirations. After coming in contact with an old friend of his father's, Gon, with a little bit on pursuasion, manages to secure a trip on a boat to the mainland, so that he may obtain a Hunter license. However, in order to get a license, he must pass a difficult qualification exam, something that, for most people, is the last thing there ever attempt. During the exam, he meets three other Hunter hopefuls, Leorio, Kurapika and Killua, and together they set off on a difficult journey that leads them into confrontations with sadistic jesters, a twelve-legged organization, and a "Game world" that's a lot more dangerous than it seems..

Ups:
HxH combines elements of epic battles with the use of wit, strength and strategy. It brings on a sense of fantastic realism in the way that the characters use their brains to win fights more often than they use violence. The animation is also excellent, combined with beautiful music and a great selection of opening and ending themes. The personalities of the characters are distinctive, and while there are few backstories, the ones that exist are described in detail.

The energy system (Nen) and how it works is a huge plus as well, being branched out and complex.

The voice actors are very good as well, each portraying the character very nicely.

Downs:
The end of the second arc was left a little loose-ended, and the lack of an animated third arc brought the series to a screeching halt. The fights are very few and far in between. Aside from the Heaven’s Arena story, there are hardly any real fights. The Hunter Exam story was a little dragged out as well.

----
I find this series to be a combination of DBZ and Chess. While all of the characters must train themselves to become stronger, they are not the strongest characters in the series. There are plenty of people more powerful than they are. There’s a lot of strategy involved in this series and a lot of pure endurance.

Another interesting thing about this series is the spiritual energy it uses. Known as “Nen,” there are different branches that are used for different things. The Nen branch Zetsu, for instance, is used to suppress one’s aura, making them hard to protect, while Ren, the will of the user, inflates the aura to use as a weapon.

Branching off even further still are the types of nen users. Like the Chakra of Naruto, there are different elements of nen that determine what kind of powers the users can learn. The nen type Reinforcement strengthens one’s hand-to-hand combat abilities, while manipulation can allow one to change the atomic structure of a solid item. Specialization users can do both of those to the max.

I find the complexity of the energies to be a very huge plus, considering it is very different from the usual monoenergies that EVERYONE has, that allows everyone to learn the same skills as everyone else.

The story in the beginning starts off very nicely, and gets to the point of the series fairly quickly. The first part of the story takes a little while to complete, but after that, pretty much everything is fast paced, and you get to see some sides of the characters that you didn’t see before. The only downfall I could find in the story was the abrupt cut off at the end of Greed Island.

The character personalities are distinct, and everyone has a reason for doing what they do, be it a need for revenge, adventure or simply because they want to. There are many characters. But everyone has a backstory that is revealed at some point in the show and manga. The characters have different powers from each other, getting rid of character cloning as far as strength or power. There are weaknesses and there are strong points.

The animation is fluid and detailed, and runs smoothly through the anime. The smooth animation and elaborate coloration create beautiful backgrounds and cutting-edge fight scenes. Each location in the story is unlike anywhere else. A forest is a forest, but the woods of another place would be distinctively different. (It takes a while to notice, but they do put detail in what plants go where. xD)

Ok.. it might just be an opinion of mine, but I personally think this is a great series that many people would enjoy. It’s interesting, funny, and it can be very dark at times. It has great music, a good plot, great characters and solid animation.

I give it a star rating of 9.7/10.

aoi_n_asul
10-19-2006, 10:35 PM
it's an interesting review. the opening line is a neat way of drawing one's attention to your review (especially, if it's their first time to hear about the anime). i like the additional tidbit you included regarding the characters' Nen. just be careful not to get carried away with elaborating on that one detail alone. clustering ideas and thoughts in separate paragraphs made it a very convenient read, however, as a whole, the review structure is loose because the paragraphs don't relate with each other, in terms of their contents. you have to have a theme to hold all your thoughts together, to make your review come as a compact whole. :chher:

Panwolf
10-20-2006, 12:46 PM
Yay! A reply!

I thought I did pretty good for a first time, but thanks for the input. Might have been better if I had put the paragraphs in a relative order than leaving them strewn about randomly. ._.;

Ieyasu
10-20-2006, 05:42 PM
You seem rather overzealous in your percentage grade.

I don't think 97% has ever been acheived on anime academy, by any anime. Hunter x Hunter may be good, but do you really think it's only 3% percent off having no faults whatsoever? I.e. being perfect?

Panwolf
10-20-2006, 08:08 PM
You seem rather overzealous in your percentage grade.

I don't think 97% has ever been acheived on anime academy, by any anime. Hunter x Hunter may be good, but do you really think it's only 3% percent off having no faults whatsoever? I.e. being perfect?

Like I said, it's an opinion. Personally, I didn't find anything wrong with it other than that cut-off at the end of the series, the slightly drawn out exam story and the lack of fighbting.(Which isn't too bad) ._.''

Somehow I think that doing this was a bad idea now..

animanic_critic
10-20-2006, 08:28 PM
Like I said, it's an opinion. Personally, I didn't find anything wrong with it other than that cut-off at the end of the series, the slightly drawn out exam story and the lack of fighbting.(Which isn't too bad) ._.''

Somehow I think that doing this was a bad idea now..
It's never a bad idea to review an anime that you love, Panwolf. I'll try to further expand what Ieyasu is implying because frankly, I agree with him to some extent.

You give Hunter X Hunter a whopping 97%, but your review doesn't really back up the exceptionally high rating. There is this portion on the anime's downfall mentions a few problems pertaining certain arcs. Are you seriously telling us that this setback costs only 3% of your rating from otherwise a perfect 100% rating? Besides that, all the positive points in the review don't justify the 97% grade as well.

I can tell that you love Hunter X Hunter, but you don't have to give such a high grade just to show it. Even if you wish to, please explain vividly why you would give such a grade. So far, your review's okay but the review contains assumptions that some readers may not understand, for instance, the concepts instilled within the series itself, Dragonball Z and Naruto.

One word of advice: If you want to write reviews, expect criticism. People don't like it since it leaves a bad "aftertaste", but it helps in the long run... a lot, just like medicine. Ieyasu's comment is hardly criticizing, and if you find it hard to swallow, I suggest you don't write reviews at all. I have my fair share of criticism with my previous anime review, but it has only inspired to write better ones in the future.

Panwolf
10-20-2006, 08:42 PM
...

No.. it's not that. I just feel like I did something entirely wrong now.

Mana
10-20-2006, 09:27 PM
No.. it's not that. I just feel like I did something entirely wrong now.

Would you mind clarifying? We are here to help you, after all. ^_^

Panwolf
10-21-2006, 06:34 AM
Would you mind clarifying? We are here to help you, after all. ^_^

They said I did something wrong with how I rated it. >.<

I don't mind criticism, but I thought that the reviews were based on the opinion of the one that wrote it.. did I misunderstand?

animanic_critic
10-21-2006, 12:46 PM
They said I did something wrong with how I rated it. >.<

I don't mind criticism, but I thought that the reviews were based on the opinion of the one that wrote it.. did I misunderstand?
No, you're on the right track. Yes, the reviews here are rated based on the writer's opinion, but the main issue is why the writer will give such a rating, and this should be discussed and clarified thoroughly in the review itself. The purpose is generally to encourage or discourage people from watching it. Some people may love a certain title, others may not, and it's their reviews that should explain why they like it or hate it.

Technically speaking, there's nothing wrong about rating the series 97%, but you better have some convincing explanation to do to justify it. Otherwise, your review may just end up sounding naive and incoherent, which hopefully isn't true.

Panwolf
10-21-2006, 08:29 PM
No, you're on the right track. Yes, the reviews here are rated based on the writer's opinion, but the main issue is why the writer will give such a rating, and this should be discussed and clarified thoroughly in the review itself. The purpose is generally to encourage or discourage people from watching it. Some people may love a certain title, others may not, and it's their reviews that should explain why they like it or hate it.

Technically speaking, there's nothing wrong about rating the series 97%, but you better have some convincing explanation to do to justify it. Otherwise, your review may just end up sounding naive and incoherent, which hopefully isn't true.

I wasn't trying to be naive. x.x The reason I rated a 97% was because there wasn't a lot of things wrong with it. I guess next time I'll write in more of the good stuff. >.<;

And looking back, I realize that I really touch anything other than characters and the Nen, so I guess that's why people didn't understand why I gave it a high rating...

Ojisan
10-22-2006, 12:36 AM
I think the biggest problem people are having here with swallowing your 97% is that it's not justified. You need to qualify your lows and the meat of your review hardly has much more than generic praise that doesn't snazz it up and make it feel like a 97%.

Examples:

The voice actors are very good as well, each portraying the character very nicely.

Sounds... above average. Not 97. Try something a little more vivid, like, "The voice acting is as near perfect as any anime can hope to achieve, conveying an acute sense of the character's personalities."

The fights are very few and far in between. Aside from the Heaven’s Arena story, there are hardly any real fights. The Hunter Exam story was a little dragged out as well...

"...however none of these minor details detract heavily from the quality of the series, they may just leave a few of the action-oriented fans in a little want."

Or something, see what I mean?


Ok.. it might just be an opinion of mine, but I personally think this is a great series that many people would enjoy.

And definately, DEFINATELY, cut that shit out. "It might just be an opinion of mine, but I personally think"...

no shit

Nothing in a review needs to be stated as an opinion, it's redundant as they are inherently so. All this does is severely weaken your writing.

There's other areas that could use a little work, but good start and keep practicing.

Panwolf
10-22-2006, 08:46 AM
Yeah, I see, and I'll just work on that next time. Thanks for the input, all. :3

lyleanna
10-22-2006, 12:10 PM
it's ok... panwolf... even me and my work are always given bad criticism.. but it's still ok.. because they're reading all your work... hahahaha better than not

Panwolf
10-22-2006, 01:09 PM
it's ok... panwolf... even me and my work are always given bad criticism.. but it's still ok.. because they're reading all your work... hahahaha better than not

That's true. xD;