Mr. Suggestion Box and Mrs. Comment Box

[Kagura]

Hajimemashite.
The meaning of this thread is to post either comments about the site (What you like, don't like, questions, should be changed, etc) and to post suggestions (what doesn't the site have that would make it better that is within the academy's grasp).

Comments:
On Reviews, there are some overplayed jokes that'll just annoy anyone:
1) The Visine Jokes (it gets the red out...)
2) The Coffee Jokes (Better switch to decaf/I wanted decaf!)
3) The consistent, "Hello Nurse!"

For someone who has too much time on their hands, if I listed anymore, I would become heir loser.

Suggestions:
Maybe there should be more on the Staff Info pages like favorites and whatnot? Many students want to know more about their professors and retired professors. What's their favorite Japanese dish? Their first anime? Tell us about themselves.

Please continue. I pray to the Lord this thread does not become inhabited by SPAM and hopefully not locked by Professors, Rit, or Roark...

[soundchazer]

Favorite Japanese dish: Tuna Sashimi
Favorite Japanese drink: Calpis
First anime: Triton of the sea, Alps no shoujo Heidi, Ie naki ko (Remi), Princess Knight.
Favorite japanese word: oppai
Favorite japanese singer: Sakamoto Maaya
Favorite Japanese car: any Toyota will do.
Favorite Kurosawa movie: as much as I like his epics, I loved "Dreams"
Favorite japanese invention: CDs
Favorite Japanese monster: Godzilla

ok... if you have more questions, ask away.

[Phelddagrif]

I like toes....

And decaf.

[Niner]

I enjoy sashimi. And the occasional small child.

[Illjwamh]

Yeah, the decaf joke was old about a year and a half ago. The DBZ movies alone wore it out.



:deadhorse

[isolatedotaku]

Suggestion: Do awards. Something like a yearly award graphic added to the pages; awards like Best Art, Best Voice Cast, Best Music, Best Drama, Best Comedy, ect.

I just think it would be awesome for some of the not-so-high-rated animes to be shown off if they qualify.

[Kagura]

Suggestion: Do awards. Something like a yearly award graphic added to the pages; awards like Best Art, Best Voice Cast, Best Music, Best Drama, Best Comedy, ect.

I just think it would be awesome for some of the not-so-high-rated animes to be shown off if they qualify.

Ooo! I love that idea! :D

I enjoy sashimi. And the occasional small child.

Relevant because? Suggestions and comments please. With the exceptions of mods and professors which I am unaware if Pheldagriff is one, but I'm doubly sure they are.

Please people, cooperate so this can become a sticky! ;)

[Admiral Ackbar]

A lot of the jokes in the reviews are often inside jokes from IRC, or at least the continuation of old inside jokes from IRC. FYI.

[Philip]

Hey, what do you all think of creating a chatroom, you know, it doesn't have to be flashy and it would help people meet others and it would make this academy more seeker-friendly. Just a thought, anyone can feel free to chip in their own two cents as well.

:computer:

[Niner]

Been there, done that. (http://www.animeacademy.com/forums/showthread.php?t=17229)

It's called IRC and has been mentioned several times in this thread already.

[Ninja Realist]

We need to find a way to stop people like Phillip from joining this forum.

[Liegenschonheit]

We need to find a way to stop people like realist from pissing people off :P

[Ninja Realist]

Actually, I'd like that too.........I honestly piss off way more people than I intend to. Case in point, Lieg getting pissed off at me for wishing there weren't spammy idiots like that joining the forum every minute. Not my intention at all. No joke, If you guys figure that out PM me or something.

[DarkKanti]

With the exceptions of mods and professors which I am unaware if Pheldagriff is one, but I'm doubly sure they are.

:jawdrop:

Pheld, a professor?

:lol2:

[Kagura]

:jawdrop:

Pheld, a professor?

:lol2:

no, no, pheld a mod.

[Admiral Ackbar]

Pheld a mod? Are you on crack?

Mod list is here: http://www.animeacademy.com/forums/showgroups.php?

[Dtortot]

Favorite useless thread: This one.

[Philip]

Been there, done that. (http://www.animeacademy.com/forums/showthread.php?t=17229)

It's called IRC and has been mentioned several times in this thread already.

Ok, sorry 'bout that. I didn't know.

Actually, I'd like that too.........I honestly piss off way more people than I intend to. Case in point, Lieg getting pissed off at me for wishing there weren't spammy idiots like that joining the forum every minute. Not my intention at all. No joke, If you guys figure that out PM me or something.

Hey man, sorry 'bout pissing you off, but whatsup with slamming me? I don't even know you and all I am doing is posting like everyone else. What the heck is up with you? You slam me on my own thread and get it closed, and you look up all the messages I've posted and slammed them all. By the way, I'm not a spammer, or an idiot. I don't have time for people like you so I'm not going to leave.

[JOJO]

Are you gonna stay because they told you to leave, or because you like pissing people of?, anyway, either choice is good. :thumbup:

[Tremolo]

Are you gonna stay because they told you to leave, or because you like pissing people of?, anyway, either choice is good. :thumbup:

Best attempt at flaming ever.

[Niner]

Philip, sorry if I came off as a bit harsh, 'twasn't my intention really. My apologies.

Favorite useless thread: This one.
What he said.

[Ninja Realist]

Hey man, sorry 'bout pissing you off, but whatsup with slamming me? I don't even know you and all I am doing is posting like everyone else. What the heck is up with you? You slam me on my own thread and get it closed, and you look up all the messages I've posted and slammed them all. By the way, I'm not a spammer, or an idiot. I don't have time for people like you so I'm not going to leave.

Unless you have another account I definetly didn't hunt down all your posts and flame them(especially considering you only have 10 posts).

Look Philip, I have very little beef with people who just make stupid posts. In fact you seem like you have good grammar and could potentially be a good poster. The thing that really rubs me the wrong way is when lazy people, who don't take the time to read the FAQ's and stickys, make comments that have allready been covered.

These people inconvenience others purely out of their own laziness. If you don't want people to get annoyed at you READ THE GODDAMN STICKIES.

[Cherika]

honestly the site is good as it is. the award things seems cool though. but other than that is already the best anime forum.

[Philip]

Unless you have another account I definetly didn't hunt down all your posts and flame them(especially considering you only have 10 posts).

Look Philip, I have very little beef with people who just make stupid posts. In fact you seem like you have good grammar and could potentially be a good poster. The thing that really rubs me the wrong way is when lazy people, who don't take the time to read the FAQ's and stickys, make comments that have allready been covered.

These people inconvenience others purely out of their own laziness. If you don't want people to get annoyed at you READ THE GODDAMN STICKIES.

Alright bro, no harm done.

Philip, sorry if I came off as a bit harsh, 'twasn't my intention really. My apologies.


What he said.
No problemo, I'm not mad or anything.

Best attempt at flaming ever.
:victory:

[Kiba]

We should be aloud to post pointless images to underline how pointless some threads are, kinda like this....

This thread is....
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y93/iseeutoo/pigeons.jpg

[Freya]

We should be aloud to post pointless images to underline how pointless some threads are, kinda like this....

This thread is....

OMFG!!!! *Lahffs super hard* ahhhhhh you crack me up.... :hyper:

[TypicalIdiotFan]

Here's a serious suggestion:

Get s'more newb avatars. If I see another newb take a FLCL, Sesshoumaru, or Tokyo Mew Mew avatar again, Imma gonna ****in' scream. If Mugs wants s'more, I'm sure the local artists here, and even myself, can set up some new small sized newb avatars.

[Niner]

That's actually a pretty good suggestion. I've got a repository of avatars from way back when I actually had time to make such things. They're smaller than usual, most at 70x70, but I think they work, so I could contribute to that too.

[JOJO]

If everyone gives at least one new avatar, then we may finally start seeing new faces around here. We could all use more jojo avatars:D.

[Zushio]

We should be aloud to post pointless images to underline how pointless some threads are, kinda like this....

This thread is....

That's A LOT of pigeons....

[Kiba]

I can contribute to the avatar thing. Mine arent the best but they are good newb ones.


EDIT: A littel off topic but wouldnt it be interesting if we had the resources to create merchandise for AA. Another website I saw even had fake school shirts and logo's and such. Just a thought.
AA has merchandise they like t-shirts or was it sweaters?

[Risen Hell Fire]

AA has merchandise they like t-shirts or was it sweaters?
it's t-shirts and i do have one infact lol.

[Risen Hell Fire]

theres already been crap about SC and someone else talking about a ANNIE sex doll. which won't happen i bet but it's just thier idea. not like it's gonna happen. maybe there should be a annie may mug.

[Risen Hell Fire]

what i thought would be a cool idea for the shirts would be having your account name on the back along with your public profile as well.

[Risen Hell Fire]

and hopefully one day we'll have our annie may comic. *hint hint* *nudge nudge* and maybe we can have little tree worm action figures in the store. edit: oh and i'm sorry if i'm spamming on this thread. my bad.

[JOJO]

An Annie May comic featuring all the regulars in the forum getting into a lot amusing situations, we could also try and include a little action to keep things more interesting.

[JOJO]

I guess it wouldn't be such a good idea to go and print this comic, after all it would just be are personal joke and the people outside of AA wouldn't undestand it.

[Demonthenes]

But that would take serious planning plus a dedicated artist that has enough skill to draw and color effectivly.

[JOJO]

Mmm, make a manga with an original story with all of us?, sort off like Tsubasa Chronicle, now that's not a bad idea.

[Demonthenes]

Might as well get a group together then Junko. But without most of us knowing each other it is a hard goal to accomplish.

[JOJO]

Well, until the day comes when one of us wins the lottery and funds the AA manga, we can still come up with the concept for the story and all the characters background.:D

[Kiba]

All newbies should be given this as their sig until they reach 100 posts...
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y93/iseeutoo/untitled.bmp

[Risen Hell Fire]

i say we should give noobs that have just register a pm message that tells them the rules. so that spam can be cut down.

[Freya]

All newbies should be given this as their sig until they reach 100 posts...
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y93/iseeutoo/untitled.bmp

*lahffs* thats the funniest thing ever..... ahhh.... i say we like, ban mean people to... *glares at Ackbar* lol jk

[Demonthenes]

All newbies should be given this as their sig until they reach 100 posts...
http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y93/iseeutoo/untitled.bmp

That was brilliant.. did you think of that yourself?

[Kiba]

That was brilliant.. did you think of that yourself?
Yes, yes I did, and Freya Ackbar's not mean he's just Canadian.

[Freya]

Yes, yes I did, and Freya Ackbar's not mean he's just Canadian.

it seems to be a trait a lot of Cunuks have ;) (just kidding m' boy) :_lol:

[Kiba]

it seems to be a trait a lot of Cunuks have ;) (just kidding m' boy) :_lol:
Thta's right you better be kidding, don't dis Crapada.

[Admiral Ackbar]

The one thing that Canadians seem to have as an advantage is that we can spell. Unless Cunuck is some sort of derogatory way of saying Canuck, in which case I fail to see the insult. And I'm not just any Canadian if you must know, I am a French-Canadian. Thus all the Canadian stereotypes are reversed.

[Risen Hell Fire]

are we able to get back on topic. please.

[Freya]

The one thing that Canadians seem to have as an advantage is that we can spell. Unless Cunuck is some sort of derogatory way of saying Canuck, in which case I fail to see the insult. And I'm not just any Canadian if you must know, I am a French-Canadian. Thus all the Canadian stereotypes are reversed.

*points to Kiba* HE told me how to spell it.... dummy... dont trust canadians... :p but no okay my suggestion: we have a list of all the smilie thingys (maybe we do and i just dont know about it) but like so we can choose anyone we want whenever... cause when i go into a reply window like, random smiles show up and if i want to use one i cant always get it ya know? ya.....

[Kiba]

*points to Kiba* HE told me how to spell it.... dummy... dont trust canadians... :p but no okay my suggestion: we have a list of all the smilie thingys (maybe we do and i just dont know about it) but like so we can choose anyone we want whenever... cause when i go into a reply window like, random smiles show up and if i want to use one i cant always get it ya know? ya.....
Click on the more option.

[Freya]

thanks! gah i never saw that before....

[Kiba]

thanks! gah i never saw that before....
Well some one needs glasses wait you do have glasses.

[Risen Hell Fire]

hmmmm...maybe we can have a AA rank system like for top posters, who has made the most threads (<.< >.> i beleave that is me), and what not.

[Elric]

hmmmm...maybe we can have a AA rank system like for top posters, who has made the most threads (<.< >.> i beleave that is me), and what not.


Well... you can arrange the member lists to see who are the top posters. Its not hard at all to do.

[Risen Hell Fire]

Well... you can arrange the member lists to see who are the top posters. Its not hard at all to do.
i'm too lazy :p but maybe we can have a hall of the banned. just to see how many people were. it won't happen i bet but it's worth a try.

[sohryu]

i'm too lazy :p but maybe we can have a hall of the banned. just to see how many people were. it won't happen i bet but it's worth a try.

I wouldn't mind that, actually. I tried searching for banned members, but I don't think you can. So, I second the motion for a hall of the banned.

[Datsun]

Yeah, I don't like the idea of a hall of shame, or a ranking to show how has started up the most threads - that would just give even more reason for pointless inane threads to be started up.

But yeah, a Hall of WTF!?! I think that would be quite interesting to archive all of those random posts and threads.

[LadySage]

Yeah, I don't like the idea of a hall of shame, or a ranking to show how has started up the most threads - that would just give even more reason for pointless inane threads to be started up.


Hall of Shame would definitely be a bad idea. Some people take pride in their poor reputations. Have you seen Jojo's sig? "I <3 Spam"

[Kuzu Ryu Sen]

I'm not so sure. It could sound a bit like a Hall of Fame to the many weirdos out there, and that might inspire them to greater and more annoying deeds.

I dunno, but if there was to be a Hall of Something, then I'd hope it would honor the kind of stuff people would want to see more of:

- Hall of Very Funny Posts That Are Very Funny Indeed
- Hall of Amazingly Kawaii Sigs and Avys
- Hall of WTF

hmmmm...maybe we can have a AA rank system like for top posters, who has made the most threads (<.< >.> i beleave that is me), and what not.


Nothing but useless pissing contests.

[JOJO]

Hall of Shame would definitely be a bad idea. Some people take pride in their poor reputations. Have you seen Jojo's sig? "I <3 Spam"
Okay first of all, i dont take pride in having a bad reputation, my impopularity started about 2 weeks after i joined AA and i'm not sure why. I sometimes have made fun of myself or went along with other that have, but its not because i like being dislike, it because i dont care and it doesnt affect me, i'm not going to get pissed at someone just because they made fun of me or because they flamed me(if that was the case, i would have been gone from here a long time ago)
And as for the "I <3 Spam" on my sig, i really don't know what that means, Elric made the sig but i doubt that he would have done it for the sole purpose of insulting me.

[sohryu]

And as for the "I <3 Spam" on my sig, i really don't know what that means

I'm only guessing here, and I could very well be wrong, but I think, think, that it might just mean that you love spam. I'm going out on a limb here, guys. Correct me if I'm wrong.

[JOJO]

I did not know that[NOT SARCASM]. Anyway, think of it as just another of my many ironies, i only care about the picture in the sig and the rest i can live with.

Edit: I hope you people are happy now!

[Erigion]

Absolutely not, anything that creates more work for moderators is bad.

[Risen Hell Fire]

Well here's somthing everyone can agree on. Lets get a Spell Check system in our post thing. Like from this other forum I'm a part of. http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v705/RHF/Spellcheckweneed.jpg If that megaman forum does it why can't we? EDIT: Oh and how about a automatic system that sends one PM to each new person that joins and have it tell them what the rules are (since we're haveing trouble with them reading it). It porbably won't happen but hey these are my ideas.

[Niner]

Or you could just learn to spell correctly.

[LadySage]

I suggest banning anyone with a period-to-word phrase of greater than 1:1

[DarkKanti]

I suggest banning anyone with a period-to-word phrase of greater than 1:1


Best. Suggestion. Evar.

[Zee'd]

... ... ... ... .... ... ...
Great, yet another example of some discrim*OooF!!*

/me gets carried away in the Van...

[Elione]

I don't know if this has been said, but, deleting people who don't post for a certain amount of time after they sign up. That should take care of some of those lurkers..

[kyubichan]

I suggest that older students be nice when they comment on a newbie's review, no matter how much it sucks. Sophomores and anyone above that should make us (freshmen) feel welcome, and that it was worth our time to join these forums.

[Risen Hell Fire]

I suggest that older students be nice when they comment on a newbie's review, no matter how much it sucks. Sophomores and anyone above that should make us (freshmen) feel welcome, and that it was worth our time to join these forums.Don't worry, people like me and AOJ will always welcome new people with open arms (unlike some people, yeah I'm looking at you Sage and Ackbar). But I can't help with the reviews problem sorry.

[LadySage]

You must be nice in commenting on reviews? Bull. The point of student reviews is for others to pick them apart, to improve on your technique while getting your opinion out there. If you're just "nice" nothing will get accomplished.

And yeah, I'm not going to be nice to people I dislike, especially if their reputation preceeds them. I'm looking at you RHF.

[Niner]

I suggest that older students be nice when they comment on a newbie's review, no matter how much it sucks. Sophomores and anyone above that should make us (freshmen) feel welcome, and that it was worth our time to join these forums.

I make it a point to take every newbie's review on an ad hoc basis. Some of them are clearly puerile pieces of crap that demonstrate no effort on the part of the writer. As such, I express my reaction, which is more often than not distaste and acerbity. Yet there are other newbie reviews, rare as they are, which exhibit a good and honest effort. These I treat with kid gloves; I critique and offer suggestions and most of the time, encouragement.

Treating all reviews in the same fashion is counter-productive. I apply this same principle to newbies. They have to make a geniune effort and not just spam and hope to make friends that way.

You must be nice in commenting on reviews? Bull. The point of student reviews is for others to pick them apart, to improve on your technique while getting your opinion out there. If you're just "nice" nothing will get accomplished.

And yeah, I'm not going to be nice to people I dislike, especially if their reputation preceeds them. I'm looking at you RHF.

Sagey ftw. If I don't like you, I won't go out of my way to get on your case, but I sure as hell ain't going to be nice to you either.

[LadySage]

(Yah know... I dont think Sage and Ackbar like that many people...)


Oh, and for the record, I like plenty of people. I don't like folks who talk in non sequiturs and blather to themselves when others are trying to engage in conversation.

[kyubichan]

Suggestions:

That people talk in English, and refrain from using their own languages such as that God-forbidden leet thing... ><

I also suggest AA change their banner thing...the girl with green hair looks deformed. T_T And yes, I am saying I can do better than that.

[Two-twenty]

Suggestions:

That people talk in English, and refrain from using their own languages such as that God-forbidden leet thing... ><
no wayz mang! taht wud meen no mor chanserv an he iz teh r0x0rz!!!1!!
I also suggest AA change their banner thing...the girl with green hair looks deformed. T_T And yes, I am saying I can do better than that.
a) She has blue hair.
b) She's somewhat popular (http://animeacademy.com/forums/showthread.php?t=14291)

No.

[Miaka Lee]

I also suggest AA change their banner thing...the girl with green hair looks deformed. T_T And yes, I am saying I can do better than that.
For a twenty year old and saying you can do better; you sure don't know your colors. If you are an art person or something like that maybe you should buy one of those color maps(trust me it will help).

Its not a suggestion; but I just want to say Thanks to everybody thats been kind to me in AA. When I started here I wasn't sure if AA people would be nice are not(thats why I've been shy to talk); now that I've been here awhile it seems just like a regular school with better subjects and I like that. Don't think that I don't have a life but...it just seems like I have a better life here that I will ever have at home.(now I've gone sappy:XD: )

*Miaka feels a little stupid

[Shadowmage]

Suggestions:

That people talk in English, and refrain from using their own languages such as that God-forbidden leet thing... ><

I also suggest AA change their banner thing...the girl with green hair looks deformed. T_T And yes, I am saying I can do better than that.
Annie May is here to stay, but changing the pic of her might be wise. I'm sure that Linuts or ASL can whip something up.

[C0MPL3X]

I'd assume that Linuts is busy with annie may comic project along with niner and zee'd (i assume this hasn't been aborted...?). I remember ASL saying this though,
When I said I would do comisioned art I was offering my services to Kain and the AA comic comitee... hehe... I would be willing to offer them some time since my work would apear as official AA stuff.
Only problem is, does ASL come here any more? Is he still interested?


And just a suggestion...would it be ok if we had a request section where people may request a review that is not listed in the library? Like people would just make a request 'can we have an anime named blablabla reviewed?'. Could be a bad idea because not many would participate--->dead section quickly. Just that the library is missing some animes I thought were well known.

[kyubichan]

@Miaka

Well, just say that she has blue hair, no need to lengthen the subject. Anyway, her hair appears green because of the effect of the blue background of the AA text.

Also, I am commenting on behalf of people who see the website for the first time. Honestly, if it were for the main page alone, I would not visit this site because of Annie May's deformed version. As a clear up, the suggestion was aimed exactly at that banner alone and not to Annie May or AA. As I said, "the girl with the green hair looks deformed", I did not say that I don't like her, or AA for that matter. In fact, I visit AA for its reviews and nothing else.

[DarkKanti]

Am I the only one not seeing the whole "deformed" thing here?

[jiffyjimbothe3]

Am I the only one not seeing the whole "deformed" thing here?
No

[Miaka Lee]

@Kyubichan

@Kyubichan

Sorry about that; got caught up in my own thing. :moron:

Annie May looks fine to me.

Though new banner with her would be nice.

[Griveton]

And just a suggestion...would it be ok if we had a request section where people may request a review that is not listed in the library? Like people would just make a request 'can we have an anime named blablabla reviewed?'. Could be a bad idea because not many would participate--->dead section quickly. Just that the library is missing some animes I thought were well known.


This has been suggested several times, in some form or another. The short and curt answer to this suggestion is no. The long and nice answer is that the AA staff has no reason to give a specific anime priority: Good, mediocre, bad, and abysmal anime are all equally deserving of a review, and thus, there is no reason to ask for a specific one: The staff will eventually get to review it sooner or later.

[C0MPL3X]

I'm sorry I should've edited my post back there. I remembered back in faq, request for reviews are not allowed because AA eventually tried to get to write reviews for every animes out there. I thought the issue died down itself but guess not.

And I dont get this deformation you speak of. Perhaps you could explain how it is aesthetiscally displeasing you, etc. I personally like the current banner. I do think it can be better, just that not many people are willing to put in a lot of effort into I assume.

[Kaito Fujiwara]

I have a suggestion: and that is to allow Arcade reviews, they don't need their own section.

[kyubichan]

@miaka

that's ok, I honestly made a mistake and thank you guys for letting me know ^^

anyway, the point of my suggestion is to draw more people into the site, you see, not everyone is as deep as we (I assume, everyone in this topic) are. what I mean is that people might come across AA but don't bother to browse here because of the banner (and for that fact, the main page) alone. let's be realistic, aesthestics usually attract more people. you might not care if people don't care about AA, but I think more people would make AA more diverse than it already is ^^

[DarkKanti]

anyway, the point of my suggestion is to draw more people into the site, you see, not everyone is as deep as we (I assume, everyone in this topic) are. what I mean is that people might come across AA but done bother to browse here because of the banner (and for that fact, the main page) alone. let's be realistic, aesthestics usually attract more people. you might not care if people don't care about AA, but I think more people would make AA more diverse than it already is ^^

Well, AA was voted the third most popular anime site two years in a row. I think they're doing just fine.

[kyubichan]

^^ then that's good ^^

btw, I posted something about members being 'nice' when they comment on student reviews, some of the reactions are rather ridiculous, taking the word nice for what it is....jeez....okay, to be more precise, I meant :
"older members ought to be objective and should point out what the problem is with a review, and not just go 'jeez, that sucks' because how in the world will the reviewer improve if no one tells him what's wrong with his review? and don't go 'but the whole thing sucks!!!', the reaction should be something like 'maybe he should redo the whole thing and start from scratch and take into account these pointers: etc.'....won't that be more constructive and helpful?" ^^

[C0MPL3X]

Something's wrong with you. Go back to page 6. Read all the crap in that page. And don't bring this up again. And this is as constructive as I can get when I'm faced with a post of such a calibre.

EDIT: Ok ok, I'll be nicer, so stop deleting my post.

Hello Kyubichan. Thank you for your concern. Did you by any chance go to room no. PAGE 6 ONWARDS like I asked you to? Just in case you haven't noticed, they have already talked about your suggestion. And please note, this is a suggestions box yes i agree with you, but this is not a spam box. Or community facility for mentally challenged people. Thank you and please come visit our facility, I mean forum any time in the future.

[kyubichan]

somethings' wrong with me? maybe you. I didn't bring it up again just so so, I just explained myself because I was the one who suggested it on the first place. also, this IS a suggestion box, if you don't like what you read, then just shut up then. or give your own opinion. but don't tell people what they should or should not post.

[Finnf00]

I have a suggestion: and that is to allow Arcade reviews, they don't need their own section.Meh come over to Anime Secrets (http:/www.animesecrets.org). We've got gaming reviews for ya (and better anime reviews than these people ;P ).

[Jeannie]

Why the hell isn't this a sticky?


Anway, I think the mod and the staff need to get together and decide on a set of guidlines regarding how the forums should be run. You see, all of the mods here (from what I've seen) are very good and do their jobs well but because they all have different ideas on what is and isn't appropriate in the forums (necro-posting, flaming, spamming, etc.). I've noticed certain mods think it's okay to revive an old thread while another thinks it's better to start a new topic and with a forum this large that creates alot of confusion for the staff and the members.

I suggest (since this is a suggestion thread) that Mugs (I've been told he is in charge of the forums?) and the mod's need to decide on what in acceptable at AA so that everyone will know what is and isn't okay and hopefully it will cut down on the whole new threads vs old thread arguement.


Thank you for your time. Make the right choice :thumbup:

[NausicaaBoy]

I think we should have more set discussions about different forms of anime...than just rag tag discussions about little random things

[Rove]

Why the hell isn't this a sticky?


Anway, I think the mod and the staff need to get together and decide on a set of guidlines regarding how the forums should be run. You see, all of the mods here (from what I've seen) are very good and do their jobs well but because they all have different ideas on what is and isn't appropriate in the forums (necro-posting, flaming, spamming, etc.). I've noticed certain mods think it's okay to revive an old thread while another thinks it's better to start a new topic and with a forum this large that creates alot of confusion for the staff and the members.

I suggest (since this is a suggestion thread) that Mugs (I've been told he is in charge of the forums?) and the mod's need to decide on what in acceptable at AA so that everyone will know what is and isn't okay and hopefully it will cut down on the whole new threads vs old thread arguement.

http://www.animeacademy.com/forums/showthread.php?t=20959 <--The unabriged version on that matters. No definite conclusion was achieved.