|
Highs: Powerful drama; strong, character-driven storyline; intertwines many themes
Lows: Starts too slow; ends too fast; key elements need fleshing out; many dead-ends
|
|
Reviewed: 04/28/2004
Grade: 79%
Please Save My Earth is for me an anime that builds you up but sadly lets you down. So many of its most promising features are weighted down by negative complements: great art with monotonous design, excellent music that rarely emerges, an inspired storyline plagued by plot holes and deep characters left hanging.
The storyline taken from Hiwatari Saki's manga is original and gripping. Every OVA leaves you on the edge of your seat and slowly integrates one of the most dramatic romance scenarios I have seen to date. Characters also add to the freshness; their unique personalities go hand in hand with poignant acting and intelligent dialogues. Rin, for example, has one of those complex psychological profiles that gave me goose bumps. Things take a wrong turn, however, when you realize it is all over and that each uncertainty that has been keeping you hooked from the beginning is still there... along with a major headache.
The pacing is quite odd. As much as it takes its sweet time slowly introducing characters in the first few episodes, the last chapters just bombard us with additional details and at the moment where you have the most questions, ends without warning. Some will see it as enigmatic; I see it as frustrating. A slow start sometimes fits an anime perfectly, as it was the case here. When it forces a rushed ending, however, is when I would rather have consistency. Emphasis also seems misplaced and unbalanced; as I was craving to see more events taking place on the moon, some negligible characters and many dead-ends stole too much of the precious spotlight.
If anime were evaluated by potential, this one would get a perfect score. Please Save My Earth is a good OVA in its own right but is far too incomplete to be placed amongst the best.
|